Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Myers, Florida

When your car makes a strange noise or a dashboard light pops on, you want a shop that’s honest, skilled, and respected by real customers. That’s why we have compiled a list of the best auto repair shops in Fort Myers, Florida, that focus on verified reviews, proven workmanship, and consistent service quality.

Furthermore, a recent survey has revealed that with car repair prices skyrocketing nationwide, working with certified repair technicians who can perfectly diagnose issues can save you money and diminish stress.  

More importantly, drivers deserve reliability, not surprises, and transparency matters more than ever. Plus, AHS Rankers keeps things transparent by relying on public reviews, hands-on expertise, and honest assessments instead of advertising dollars.

Therefore, we rolled up our sleeves and handled the tough part for you. Let’s dive into our expertly curated list of the best of the best and trusted names in Fort Myers, Florida.

Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Myers, Florida

Before we dive into the rankings, here’s the thing: every shop on this list earned its spot through real customer feedback, verified Google ratings, and hands-on expertise, not paid placement. While many go above and beyond, with low pricing, soft communication, and a reputation built on proven experiences by customers.

1. Take 5 Oil Change – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (916+ Reviews)

Address: 13990 N Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33903

Phone: (239) 984-1522

Website: Visit Site

With a strong rating, Take 5 Oil Change is a go-to stop for drivers who want fast, dependable service without leaving their vehicle. This shop is known for its 10-minute stay-in-your-car oil changes, friendly technicians, and consistent pricing.

Take 5 also handles smaller maintenance tasks such as air filters, cabin filters, coolant exchanges, wiper blades, tire pressure checks, and more.

Customers repeatedly point out how welcoming and knowledgeable the team is. Names like Kyle, Sutter, Brenton, and others appear across reviews, praised for honesty, efficiency, and taking the time to explain what a vehicle actually needs. While reviewers have also appreciated how the staff works in sync, greets every customer with the same energy, and keeps the experience simple.

In the same way, many customers note reasonable prices, quick turnaround, and above-and-beyond service, whether it’s topping off fluids, swapping filters, or checking coolant issues.

Besides, if you need a no-hassle oil change handled by a team that genuinely seems to care, this location makes it easy.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Boca Raton, Florida

2. Legendary Automotive and Truck Service – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (853+ Reviews)

Address: 1921 Courtney Dr., Fort Myers, FL 33901

Phone: (239) 277-1004

Website: Visit Site

Legendary Automotive and Truck Service earns its name with a rating from reviews and a reputation for meticulous work across nearly all makes and models. Plus, this family-run shop is known for transparent communication, deep technical expertise, and a philosophy built around “getting it done right the first time.” Legendary is also recognized by AAA as the top shop in Fort Myers, which reinforces its credibility.

Their services include oil changes, tires, brakes, A/C repairs, wheel alignments, transmission service, diesel and fleet work, and a 3-year/36,000-mile warranty that customers genuinely value.

Here’s what real customers are saying: attention to detail is unmatched, diagnostics are thorough, and the staff, names like Jason, Matt, Manny, and Julian, consistently go the extra mile. Drivers bring everything from Toyota and Honda daily drivers to Corvettes, diesel trucks, and Sprinter vans, and the shop handles them with confidence.

Whether it’s a complex engine concern or a safety inspection before a long trip, reviewers appreciate quick turnaround times, honest recommendations, and clear explanations. For anyone who wants a trustworthy, detail-oriented shop, Legendary lives up to its name.

3. Terry Wynter Auto Service Center – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (737+ Reviews)

Address: 3811 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

Phone: (239) 939-2500

Website: Visit Site

Terry Wynter Auto Service Center stands out as one of Fort Myers’ most trusted small-business repair shops and a long-time local favorite. This family-owned shop blends advanced diagnostics with an old-fashioned commitment to honesty and care.

This auto repair center is also recognized as one of Southwest Florida’s largest tire centers. While it’s ASE Blue Seal of Excellence recognition further reinforces their credibility

For 22 years, they’ve built a reputation for handling everything from routine maintenance to major engine work, tune-ups, electrical issues, transmission repairs, and more.

What customers appreciate most is their mix of integrity, transparency, and technical expertise. Reviewers frequently mention standout team members like Juan, AJ, and Darren, often praised for their patience, clear communication, and genuine concern for each customer’s situation.

Likewise, many reviewers have highlighted how the team goes above and beyond, whether it’s sourcing a transmission with a major warranty, helping elderly customers in tough situations, or offering guidance that saves clients’ money.

Above all, the shop also offers conveniences such as a courtesy shuttle, night drop-off, free Wi-Fi, a workstation, and a comfortable waiting area.  For drivers seeking detailed diagnostics with personal attention, Terry Wynter sets the bar high.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Bradenton, Florida

4. Karr Automotive – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.9⭐ (629+ Reviews)

Address: 3120 Winkler Ave #6, Fort Myers, FL 33916

Phone: (239) 768-1900

Website: Visit Site

Earning an impressive rating from reviewers, Karr Automotive is one of Fort Myers’ highest-rated independent repair shops, and a go-to for customers who want dealership-level expertise without the dealership-level hassle.

Plus, Karr specializes in general automotive repair, fleet maintenance, full engine and transmission work, brake services, oil changes, tire repairs, suspension expertise, and precision wheel alignments.

Customers often praise Karr for fixing issues that other mechanics misdiagnosed, including complex electrical problems, persistent drivability issues, and major component failures. Similarly, many reviewers have highlighted fast turnaround, clean service bays, and exceptional communication.

Their facility runs like a “well-oiled machine,” as reviews consistently put it, with a climate-controlled workshop, modern diagnostic equipment, and a team known for accuracy and efficiency. Technicians like John and the team earn frequent mentions for clear explanations, fair pricing, and photo-based repair documentation that builds trust.

Adding more, whether it’s a simple sensor replacement or a full engine job handled through extended warranty coverage. Karr’s blend of professionalism, transparency, and deep technical knowledge makes it one of the most reliable choices in Fort Myers for drivers who value both precision and customer care.

5. Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.7⭐ (606+ Reviews)

Address: 3263 Colonial Blvd, Unit A, Fort Myers, FL 33966

Phone: (239) 277-7655

Website: Visit Site

Tuffy Tire & Auto Service Center is one of those rare places where national-level resources meet small-town attentiveness. More importantly, this shop consistently delivers the kind of transparency and reliability drivers appreciate.

Therefore, this auto repair shop is also well-known across Fort Myers for its wide range of services, alignments, brakes, tires, suspension, diagnostics, and complete maintenance.

Furthermore, customers and reviewers after the review have highlighted the same theme: a team that genuinely cares. From Hannah’s friendly communication and detailed digital reports to Tony’s clear explanations and problem-solving approach, customers feel informed rather than pressured.

In the same way, drivers mention fair pricing, quick turnarounds, and a staff that remembers you the moment you walk through the door.

Above all, if you need a major diagnostic, routine upkeep, or a safety concern that needs careful attention, Tuffy keeps earning trust by doing the fundamentals right, every visit, and every customer.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Cape Coral, Florida

6. Johnny Myers Discount Tires & Service Center – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (453+ Reviews)

Address: 4248 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

Phone: (239) 936-4313

Website: Visit Site

Johnny Myers Discount Tires & Service Center has built a reputation in Fort Myers that spans generations, and the customer feedback explains why. This auto repair center is known for honesty first, value second, and exceptional workmanship throughout.

Moreover, whether it’s taking extra time to explain a check-engine issue, oil change, minor repair, squeezing in a tire repair, or giving honest second opinions that save customers money.

Customers and reviewers have frequently called out Joe, Don, and Will for going above and beyond. While many longtime locals say they’ve been coming here for 10, 15, or even 20 years because the experience never changes: friendly service, clear communication, and work done right the first time.

Drivers trust them with everything from daily commuter cars to high-performance vehicles like the Toyota Supra, praising their consistency, transparency, and fair pricing. If you want a shop that treats every vehicle like it matters, Johnny Myers continues to be a standout in the community.

7. Superior Auto Care – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (440+ Reviews)

Address: 12238 Palm Beach Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33905

Phone: (239) 694-8880

Website: Visit Site

Superior Auto Care has become a trusted name in the Fort Myers Shores area thanks to its blend of technical expertise and customer-first communication. The shop also owns ASE-certified mechanics who handle everything from AC work and oil changes to engine repairs, alignments, and brake jobs, with same-day service available on certain repairs.

Additionally, customers appreciate the detailed inspection reports with photos, fair pricing, and straightforward recommendations without upselling. In the same way, many reviewers have repeatedly mentioned the clarity and transparency of the process, especially Scott’s consistent updates and willingness to explain every detail.

New residents say the shop immediately earns their trust, while longtime locals praise the consistent workmanship and reliability over the years.

Besides, whether you’re troubleshooting a vibration, replacing major components, or simply staying on top of maintenance, Superior Auto Care stands out for its professionalism and genuine commitment to doing the job right.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Coral Springs, Florida

8. Firestone Complete Auto Care – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.0⭐ (436+ Reviews)

Address: 4420 Executive Cir, Fort Myers, FL 33916

Phone: (239) 900-1424 / (239) 603-6478

Website: Visit Site

Firestone Complete Auto Care on Executive Circle remains a dependable option for drivers who want the convenience of a national brand combined with a team that truly values customer service.

While Firestone locations can vary, this Fort Myers team has earned standout praise for its current management and exceptional front-desk service, especially Jolene, who is mentioned again and again for her professionalism, warmth, and advocacy during warranty-related repairs.

This auto repair shop is well-known for oil changes, tires, alignments, brakes, and full-system repairs. Plus, this shop handles vehicles of every make and model.

Longtime customers say the service quality has improved significantly, and reviewers have also highlighted honest inspections, quick scheduling, and technicians who catch issues before they become major problems.

Above all, if you’re a local or passing through, this shop delivers reliable, straightforward service supported by a crew that works hard to keep people safe on the road.

9. Lou’s Total Car Care – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.6⭐ (416+ Reviews)

Address: 4531 S Cleveland Ave, Fort Myers, FL 33907

Phone: (239) 278-1682

Website: Visit Site

Lou’s Total Car Care is the kind of family-run shop people stick with for years because they know the work will be done right the first time. This auto repair shop has the best of the best mechanics and can handle general automotive repairs, collision work, diagnostics, and even boat painting, a rare combination backed by skilled technicians who take pride in their craft.

Customers talk about the spotless facility, Lou’s master-level expertise, and the shop’s ability to fix issues that other places misdiagnosed or simply couldn’t tackle. Plus, the reviewers have frequently mentioned Rachael and Orlando for their professionalism and kindness, especially during unexpected breakdowns.

Classic car owners trust Lou with high-value restorations, while everyday drivers appreciate fair prices, honest assessments, and a team that steps up in stressful situations. So, with decades of experience and a reputation for transparency, Lou’s continues to be a reliable go-to for both intricate repairs and routine maintenance.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Clearwater, Florida

10. Superior Auto Care – Fowler St. – Fort Myers, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (263+ Reviews)

Address: 4100 Fowler St, Fort Myers, FL 33901

Phone: (239) 603-3860

Website: Visit Site

The Fowler Street location of Superior Auto Care mirrors the brand’s reputation for thorough, honest, and efficient service. Backed by ASE certifications, AAA Approval, and NAPA Auto Care standards, the team delivers reliable repairs without inflated recommendations.

This shop handles everything from oil changes and AC repairs to transmission work, electronic diagnostics, and full undercarriage services.

Many customers and reviewers have also highlighted Dan and Tom for their clear communication and quick turnaround times, even on complex repairs like steering and AC issues.

First-time visitors say the shop earns their trust quickly with straightforward explanations and zero pressure. The digital inspection reports, comfortable waiting area, and consistent follow-ups show their attention to detail.

Besides, if you need a simple battery replacement or major component repairs, this Fowler St. team has built a strong local following for professionalism, fair pricing, and workmanship that holds up.

Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Myers, Florida – Summary Table

Conclusion

Concluding the above discussion, we are sure that now you will be able to find the best auto repair shops in Fort Myers, Florida. Similarly, a mechanic you can trust, especially when your daily routine depends on a reliable car.

Moreover, this guide has focused on auto repair shops with proven reputations and reliability, not paid placements or sponsored listings. What this really means is you’re looking at businesses that earned their rankings through real customer experiences, certified technicians, and consistent results.

If you’re exploring other cities or need help choosing the right shop for your situation, feel free to browse more of our guides or reach out anytime. We’re here to point you toward the places that actually stand behind their work.