Let me tell you frankly! Finding the right mechanic isn’t just about fixing a car; it’s about trusting someone with your safety, time, and money. That’s why the best auto repair shops in Flagstaff, Arizona, that we’ve highlighted show how Flagstaff’s local repair community goes above and beyond.
Hence, whether that’s helping stranded travelers, keeping family cars roadworthy, or offering honest advice when it matters most. The right auto repair shop can keep your vehicle reliable, safe, and ready for long drives through Flagstaff’s mountain roads and beyond.
At AHS Rankers, we’re proud to spotlight shops that earn their place through verified reviews and genuine community feedback. Unlike paid directories or sponsored ads, our rankings are independent and rooted in real customer voices.
Likewise, exploring auto repair options in other cities or needing guidance on where to turn next, our guides are here to help you make confident, informed decisions. Here’s our expertly curated list of the most trusted names in Flagstaff, Arizona.
Let’s dive into the complete details to go through them one by one!
Best Auto Repair Shops In Flagstaff, Arizona
Flagstaff drivers need shops that combine technical know-how with honesty and consistent customer care. Based on reviews, ratings, and local feedback, these businesses have built reputations worth paying attention to.
1. Jiffy Lube Multicae – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.7★ (1.7K+ Reviews)
Address: 2740 S Woodlands Village Blvd, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 213-1313
Website: Visit Site
Jiffy Lube Multicare has long been a go-to for fast, reliable maintenance in Flagstaff. Their hallmark is efficiency: a 15-minute oil change with a free preventive maintenance review.
Beyond oil changes, the shop handles brake services, battery replacements, tire services, and even transmission and coolant flushes.
Customers appreciate the flexibility of staying in their cars or waiting in a clean, welcoming lounge. What makes this location stand out is consistency. Customers note that technicians explain issues clearly without pressure, while others emphasize the quick turnaround and fair pricing.
Additionally, many reviewers praise the team’s professionalism, frequently mentioning specific staff members by name and so, making this the balance of speed and thoroughness that keeps drivers returning again and again.
Whether it’s routine upkeep or more detailed fluid services, Jiffy Lube’s crew has earned trust through transparency and skill.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Goodyear, Arizona
2. University Auto Repair – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.6★ (1.1K+ Reviews)
Address: 1864 S Woodlands Village Blvd, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 707-8596 / (928) 433-0025
Website: Visit Site
With roots dating back to 1981, University Auto Repair is one of Flagstaff’s longest-standing shops. Now operating from a modern facility, it continues to serve both everyday drivers and fleet accounts with ASE-certified expertise.
This auto repair shop, known for handling everything from brake and transmission repair to advanced diagnostics, they’ve also been voted “Best Brake Repairs & Oil Changes” locally for more than seven years.
Customers highlight technicians who take time to explain issues clearly, offer fair pricing, and keep communication open throughout the process.
Reviews repeatedly praise their ability to help in urgent situations, whether it’s a cross-country traveler stranded by a breakdown or a local driver with last-minute needs.
The shop’s mix of decades-long community presence and a customer-first approach has made University Auto Repair a trusted stop for both residents and travelers passing through Flagstaff.
3. Meineke Car Care Center – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.5★ (1K+ Reviews)
Address: 1830 East Route 66, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 255-0907
Website: Visit Site
Meineke Car Care Center has been part of the American auto repair scene since 1972, expanding from mufflers to a full-service operation. In Flagstaff, their shop covers everything from AC and exhaust repairs to tire replacements and oil changes.
Plus, they’ve built a reputation for being approachable, affordable, and flexible with both local drivers and road-trippers passing through Route 66.
What stands out in reviews is their ability to help in emergencies. Customers share stories of overheating vehicles, long-distance breakdowns, or sudden check-engine lights, all fixed quickly and at fair prices. Many mention technicians by name, like Carl and Donovan, for their honesty and personal care.
Fast turnaround, straightforward communication, and a willingness to fit travelers in without hesitation make Meineke a lifeline for many. It’s that mix of national brand backing and hometown reliability that keeps people coming back.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Lake Havasu City, Arizona
4. Murphy’s Heavy Towing, Off-Road Recovery & Semi Truck Repair
Rating: 4.8★ (714+ Reviews)
Address: 5385 N Dodge Ave, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 853-5202
Website: Visit Site
Murphy’s Heavy Towing is more than just a tow service; it’s a full recovery and repair operation trusted across northern Arizona. Available 24/7, they handle everything from light-duty roadside calls to heavy truck recovery, semi-trailer hauling, and even off-road rescues.
Adding more, their team is ASE-certified and Cummins-certified in medium and heavy trucks, making them a critical resource for both local fleets and travelers hauling through I-40.
Customer feedback highlights not only their technical expertise but also their responsiveness and compassion.
Similarly, reviewers mention quick response times during stressful breakdowns, fair pricing compared to competitors, and mechanics who go above and beyond to explain every step. Names like Pancho, Chris, and Jessica come up repeatedly as staff who turn stressful situations into manageable ones.
Whether it’s a stranded RV family or a long-haul trucker with a blown radiator, Murphy’s team has proven themselves reliable, professional, and indispensable in Flagstaff’s rugged terrain.
5. Big O Tires – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.4+ (491+ Reviews)
Address: 2469 N Walgreens St, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 440-2669
Website: Visit Site
Big O Tires has earned the tagline “The Team You Trust” for a reason. Their Flagstaff location is known for friendly, straightforward service and a wide range of offerings, from tire brands like Michelin and Goodyear to brake repair, AC service, alignments, and battery replacements. They also make things convenient with early, late, and weekend appointments.
Reviews highlight both speed and professionalism. Travelers often mention being helped during emergencies, like a blown tire or unexpected breakdown while on the road.
Managers James Romero Jr. and BJ stand out in feedback for treating customers like neighbors, getting people back on the road quickly, and even going the extra mile to adjust details like tire pressure on the spot.
Locals also appreciate reasonable prices and honest advice, making Big O a dependable choice for everyday auto needs and cross-country emergencies alike.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Buckeye, Arizona
6. Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.3★ (351+ Reviews)
Address: 3735 N Kaspar Dr, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 440-1760
Website: Visit Site
Pep Boys has been around for over a century, and their Flagstaff shop carries that legacy of reliable service. From routine oil changes and new tires to brake repairs, alignments, and hybrid or EV care, their certified technicians cover a full range of vehicle needs.
Customer feedback consistently mentions manager Devin and his team for being knowledgeable, professional, and no-nonsense. Many long-term locals say they’ve trusted this location for years, appreciating transparent communication and no pushy upselling.
Travelers, too, report being helped during breakdowns or tight schedules, with mechanics explaining work clearly and finding discount options when possible.
Besides, Same-day service options are a major plus for busy drivers or travelers needing quick turnaround. Whether it’s a simple tire rotation or an urgent alternator replacement, Pep Boys Flagstaff delivers dependable results backed by decades of brand credibility.
7. Seven-Day Auto Service – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.5★ (325+ Reviews)
Address: 2101 N 3rd St, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 774-0808
Website: Visit Site
Seven Day Auto Service lives up to its name by being one of the few local shops open every day, including weekends. Their ASE-certified technicians handle all makes and models with modern diagnostic tools and a reputation for treating customers like family.
Services range from brake and alignment work to engine repairs, AC service, and fluid maintenance, all backed by warranties on both parts and labor.
Reviews highlight how often the team comes through for travelers and locals during emergencies. From fixing breakdowns on cross-country road trips to getting vehicles road-ready overnight, customers consistently praise their speed and fairness.
Many call out individual mechanics for kindness and transparency, noting that issues are explained clearly without guesswork or upselling.
Above all, being open Sundays and offering honest, efficient repairs makes Seven Day Auto a lifeline for Flagstaff drivers who can’t wait until Monday.
8. Caliber Collision – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.7★ (264+ Reviews)
Address: 3775 E Huntington Dr, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 526-1788
Website: Visit Site
Caliber Collision is part of a national leader in auto body repair, but the Flagstaff location feels distinctly local in its customer care. Their certified technicians use state-of-the-art equipment to handle everything from dent removal and paintless repairs to major collision damage.
Every repair comes with a limited lifetime warranty, giving customers peace of mind long after they leave the shop.
What sets them apart from the rest of the others, according to reviews, is communication and compassion. Customers mention being kept updated throughout the repair process and often note how the staff went above and beyond, from helping with rental cars to securing the right parts.
Advisors like Chris and Dakota get frequent shout-outs for professionalism and empathy, especially when customers are dealing with stressful accident situations. For reliable, warranty-backed body work, Caliber Collision has earned its strong reputation in Flagstaff.
9. Randy’s Downtown Garage – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.4★ (184+ Reviews)
Address: 302 East Route 66, Flagstaff, AZ 86001
Phone: (928) 220-3881 / (928) 774-1006
Website: Visit Site
Randy’s Downtown Garage is a family-owned shop rooted in Flagstaff’s historic downtown, where Nicole and her team treat every repair like helping a neighbor.
They provide complete automotive care, covering gas and diesel engines, hybrids, EVs, and everything in between. From routine oil changes and alignments to transmission work, tune-ups, and cooling system repairs, their shop is truly full-service.
Travelers and locals alike praise how Randy steps up in emergencies. Reviewers describe being stranded with overheating engines, cracked radiators, or sudden breakdowns, and still being back on the road within hours.
Customers highlight the staff’s honesty, willingness to explain options, and fair pricing, even in stressful situations. Names like Kai and Andy get frequent shout-outs for patience and clear communication.
With its mix of family values and technical expertise, Randy’s is a trusted stop for both residents and road trippers passing through Route 66.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Surprise, Arizona
10. Flagstaff Auto Repair – Flagstaff, AZ
Rating: 4.4★ (165+ Reviews)
Address: 3830 E Huntington Dr Ste 9, Flagstaff, AZ 86004
Phone: (928) 526-9159
Website: Visit Site
Flagstaff Auto Repair has been serving the community for more than 30 years, building a reputation for dependable work on both cars and light trucks. Their certified technicians handle everything from oil changes and brake service to full engine and transmission replacements.
Customers also rely on them for AC recharge, electrical diagnostics, suspension work, clutch repairs, and wheel alignments, making this shop a one-stop destination for nearly any repair.
What makes this shop stand out in reviews is its fairness and responsiveness. Travelers describe being squeezed into a packed schedule when other shops couldn’t help, while locals appreciate the upfront estimates and clear explanations before any work begins.
Many customers mention the speed of service, getting brakes or alternators replaced in just a few hours, and the welcoming staff who keep stress low in urgent situations. With decades of experience and a focus on honesty, Flagstaff Auto Repair remains a steady choice for reliable, long-term vehicle care.
Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Flagstaff, Arizona – Summary Table
| Rank | Shop Name | Rating | Specialties | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Jiffy Lube Multicare – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.7★ | Oil & Brake Service | Visit Site |
| 2 | University Auto Repair – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.6★ | Diagnostics & Brakes | Visit Site |
| 3 | Meineke Car Care Center – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.5★ | AC & Exhaust Repair | Visit Site |
| 4 | Murphy’s Heavy Towing & Truck Repair | 4.8★ | Towing & Truck Repair | Visit Site |
| 5 | Big O Tires – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.4★ | Tires & Brake Repair | Visit Site |
| 6 | Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.3★ | Tires & EV Service | Visit Site |
| 7 | Seven Day Auto Service – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.5★ | Engine & Brake Repair | Visit Site |
| 8 | Caliber Collision – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.7★ | Collision & Body Work | Visit Site |
| 9 | Randy’s Downtown Garage – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.4★ | Transmission & Cooling | Visit Site |
| 10 | Flagstaff Auto Repair – Flagstaff, AZ | 4.4★ | Engine & Suspension | Visit Site |
Conclusion
Concluding the remarks! So you’re searching for the best auto repair shops in Flagstaff, Arizona, is over; thus, the options above represent the businesses customers consistently trust for fair pricing, quality workmanship, and dependable service.
Each shop has built its reputation through years of hands-on expertise, real customer experiences, and a commitment to treating people right, not just turning wrenches.
Moreover, the drivers can now fully trust all these auto repair shops; a trustworthy mechanic can fix your damage in no time, and you can go to them for your own desired needs. So that’s why choosing the right shops carefully matters.
