Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Kissimmee, Florida

Let me be completely honest, a car trouble has a way of showing up at the worst possible time. A flat tire before work. Brakes that start squealing on a busy road. And suddenly, you’re searching for the best auto repair shops in Kissimmee, Florida, hoping to avoid overpriced quotes or rushed repairs.

Here’s the reality: more than 70% of drivers say they’ve felt unsure or pressured during a repair visit. That’s exactly why choosing a shop with real reviews and proven consistency matters.

Furthermore, with repair prices rising across the country, choosing certified mechanics who can pinpoint problems the first time isn’t just smart; it can save you money and the frustration of repeat visits and guesswork. Additionally, this guide is built from public feedback, Google ratings, and real customer experiences, not paid placements.

Above all, if reliability, transparency, and proven workmanship matter to you, you’re in the right place. Therefore, here at AHS Rankers, we cut through the noise by relying on real customer experiences, practical industry insights, and clear evaluations, without letting ads or paid placements shape the rankings.

Let’s explore these best auto repair centers that are the most expert, professional, and trusted ones in Kissimmee, Florida.

Best Auto Repair Shops In Kissimmee, Florida

Finding the right repair shop isn’t about flashy ads. It’s about consistency, transparency, and how customers are treated when things go wrong. Let’s dive into the best auto repair shops in Kissimmee locations that drivers consistently rely on.

1. Pep Boys Auto Service & Tires – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.2⭐ (1.3K+ Reviews)

Address: 302 W Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (407) 502-3156 | (407) 933-0055

Website: Visit Site

Pep Boys on West Vine Street stands out for one simple reason: it delivers dealer-level services without dealer-level pressure. What really catches attention is how often customers compare Pep Boys favorably against dealerships, citing faster service and significantly lower costs.

This location handles a wide range of services, including tire installation, brake repairs, oil changes, wheel alignments, battery replacement, and general maintenance.

Customers regularly mention fair pricing, quick turnaround times, and staff who explain repairs without talking down to them. That matters, especially if you’re not a mechanic and just want straight answers.

Similarly, several reviews have highlighted same-day repairs and appointments that actually stay on schedule. Others point to staff members like Raymond, Marcos, and Marcus for being patient, knowledgeable, and honest about what a vehicle truly needs, no upselling, no surprises.

Would you trust your brakes to just anyone? Many locals already do. With over a century as a brand and consistently strong feedback at this location, Pep Boys remains a dependable option for both routine maintenance and urgent fixes.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Jacksonville, Florida

2. RNR Tire Express – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.9⭐ (1.8K+ Reviews)

Address: 301 W Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (407) 217-9294 | (407) 305-3538

Website: Visit Site

RNR Tire Express has built a reputation in Kissimmee that’s hard to ignore. A 4.9-star rating across nearly two thousand reviews doesn’t happen by accident. Plus, payment flexibility is its major draw, especially for drivers facing unexpected tire issues.

This shop specializes in tires, wheels, balancing, and repairs, but the experience goes deeper than that. Free lifetime rotations and balancing, nitrogen fills, and roadside assistance are included with tire purchases.

Customers appreciate being shown what’s wrong, why it matters, and what can wait. That kind of clarity builds trust fast. Reviews repeatedly mention Jorge, Julio, and Juan for their professionalism and transparency. Some have consistently talked about honesty, affordability, and a team that takes the time to educate instead of rushing people out the door.

Some old visitors are saying, fair prices, fast service, and no pressure. Whether it’s a last-minute tire replacement or a full set of wheels, RNR Tire Express has earned its place as one of Kissimmee’s most trusted automotive service stops.

3. Mavis Tires & Brakes – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.7⭐ (1K+ Reviews)

Address: 4135 W Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (407) 917-4651 | (407) 316-2556

Website: Visit Site

Mavis Tires & Brakes on West Vine Street earns trust the old-fashioned way, by being honest, responsive, and consistent. That kind of reliability matters when you’re already having a rough day.

This location handles everything from tire sales and installations to brakes, alignments, oil changes, suspension work, and exhaust repairs.

Customers repeatedly mention how approachable the staff is, especially when dealing with stressful, last-minute issues like dead batteries or sudden tire pressure drops. Hence, what stands out in the reviews isn’t just speed, but clarity. Technicians like Phillip, Jose, Pedro, and Andy are often named for explaining problems plainly and fixing only what’s necessary.

In the same way, many customers specifically say they trust this shop because they’ve never felt taken advantage of. That’s especially important for drivers who’ve had bad experiences elsewhere. Emergency visits are handled quickly, pricing is described as fair, and repairs are often completed faster than expected.

Would you trust a shop you’ve been returning to for six years? Plenty of locals already do. Mavis has clearly earned repeat business by focusing on service, not sales pressure.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Hollywood, Florida

4. Tire Kingdom – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.4⭐ (836+ Reviews)

Address: 325 W Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (407) 917-5002 | (407) 431-0175

Website: Visit Site

Tire Kingdom on West Vine Street has built a strong reputation for staying calm when customers can’t. Flat tires, unexpected repairs, and tight schedules, reviews show the staff excels at guiding people through stressful moments without rushing or upselling.

Above all, this auto repair shop offers tire sales, brake repairs, alignments, oil changes, suspension work, and more.

What this really means is simple: people feel listened to. Customers frequently point out how team members like Ray, Griselle, Will, and Robert take the time to explain options clearly, especially when budgets are tight. That transparency shows up again and again in feedback.

While several reviewers have described situations where a repair could have turned into a costly replacement, the team first checked if a simple fix would work. When replacement was necessary, customers say pricing and reasoning were explained up front.

Moreover, many drivers have mentioned they now return here exclusively for routine maintenance. Consistent service, honest communication, and a staff that treats people like individuals, not transactions, are why Tire Kingdom continues to earn trust in Kissimmee.

5. Tires Plus – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.2⭐ (693+ Reviews)

Address: 816 W Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (321) 337-0635 | (407) 329-7510

Website: Visit Site

Tires Plus on West Vine Street is the kind of place drivers end up at during stressful moments and leave feeling relieved. Flat tires on road trips, last-minute repairs on a Sunday, or routine maintenance that can’t wait.

Besides, this location can handle tires, oil changes, brakes, alignments, batteries, and engine tune-ups for a wide range of vehicles.

What stands out is how often customers mention staff members like John, Josiah, Ramon, and David for explaining options without pressure. That “no judgment” approach makes a difference, especially when repairs aren’t cheap. Plus, the reviewers have consistently pointed to a team that stays calm, clear, and respectful when it matters most.

Here’s what real customers are saying: pricing is competitive, work is efficient, and the shop respects your time. Several others have highlighted being in and out in under 30 minutes for tire repairs, even during busy periods. Others appreciate honest guidance on future maintenance without being pushed to do it immediately.

Would you trust a shop you’ve returned to for over a decade? Many locals already do. Tires Plus earns loyalty by keeping things straightforward and fair.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Gainesville, Florida

6. Jiffy Lube – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.3⭐ (690+ Reviews)

Address: 109 E Vine St, Kissimmee, FL 34744

Phone: (407) 870-0790

Website: Visit Site

Jiffy Lube on East Vine Street is built for speed, but not at the expense of honesty. Managers and staff like Javier, Nick, Mateo, and the rest of the team are frequently mentioned for being professional, approachable, and genuinely helpful.

Moreover, this auto repair shop specializes in fast oil changes, brake service, batteries, tire maintenance, and preventative vehicle care.

Customers often come in expecting a quick oil change and leave impressed by how clearly everything is explained. That balance of efficiency and transparency shows up again and again in reviews. Several reviews note service times under 10–15 minutes, even during busy hours.

Similarly, many drivers highlight how technicians walk them through what their vehicle needs and what can wait. No upselling. No pressure. Just clear information.

Here’s the thing, quick doesn’t have to mean careless. For routine maintenance done right, this Jiffy Lube continues to earn repeat visits from Kissimmee drivers who value both speed and trust.

7. Take 5 Oil Change – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.6⭐ (621+ Reviews)

Address: 1907 N Main St, Kissimmee, FL 34744

Phone: (407) 705-3044

Website: Visit Site

Take 5 Oil Change on North Main Street is built for drivers who value speed but still want to feel informed. The service is fast, often around ten minutes, but what stands out is the communication.

This auto repair shop focuses on quick oil changes, filters, fluid top-offs, tire pressure checks, and light maintenance.

Customers consistently mention staying in their car, being walked through each step, and never feeling pressured to add services they don’t need. That alone sets the tone. Technicians like Eduard, Jay, Hector, Xavier, and Mya are frequently praised for explaining options clearly and showing customers what’s being done in real time.

Here’s the thing: fast service usually raises red flags. At Take 5, reviews suggest the opposite. Pricing is described as fair, quotes don’t change mid-service, and discounts are offered without being asked. Several drivers mention being alerted to small issues early, helping them avoid bigger repairs later.

Would you rather wait hours or stay in your seat with full visibility? For many Kissimmee drivers, the answer is easy.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Hialeah, Florida

8. All Car Shop – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.6⭐ (529+ Reviews)

Address: 1755 S John Young Pkwy, Kissimmee, FL 34741

Phone: (407) 847-8433

Website: Visit Site

All Car Shop isn’t built on speed; it’s built on trust. This locally respected repair shop has earned a loyal following by focusing on honest diagnostics, clear explanations, and repairs that actually solve the problem the first time.

As a NAPA AutoCare Center with ASE-certified technicians, All Car Shop handles everything from brake repairs and engine diagnostics to cooling systems, oil changes, tire services, and hybrid repairs.

Customers repeatedly mention how staff members like Jose and Joe take the time to explain what’s urgent, what can wait, and why. Plus, several reviews compare their quotes favorably against dealerships, sometimes at a fraction of the cost. Same-day repairs, detailed digital reports, and a comfortable waiting area also get high marks.

Here’s what real customers are saying: this shop saves people money. Would you trust a shop while traveling out of state? Many visitors already have, and left confident enough to recommend it. All Car Shop continues to earn its reputation the right way.

9. Caliber Collision – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.7⭐ (456+ Reviews)

Address: 2554 N Orange Blossom Trail, Kissimmee, FL 34744

Phone: (407) 870-8686

Website: Visit Site

Caliber Collision steps in when things go beyond routine maintenance. Accidents are stressful enough; customers consistently say this location makes the repair process feel organized, predictable, and far less overwhelming. Plus, reviews repeatedly highlight clear communication from start to finish.

This shop specializes in auto body repairs, bumper replacements, dent removal, fender work, and full collision restoration.

Customers appreciate receiving realistic timelines, regular updates by text, and vehicles being ready exactly when promised or earlier. Likewise, multiple reviewers mention their vehicles looking brand new after major damage. Staff members like Freddy, Jahaira, Bryan, and the rest of the team are often recognized for professionalism, compassion, and going the extra mile during difficult situations.

Here’s what real customers are saying: the workmanship is precise. Would you trust a shop after an accident? Many drivers return here more than once. Backed by a limited lifetime warranty and a national reputation, Caliber Collision earns confidence by delivering consistent, high-quality results when it matters most.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Daytona Beach, Florida

10. RepairTech Automotive – Kissimmee, FL

Rating: 4.8⭐ (358+ Reviews)

Address: 2968 Michigan Ave, Ste. I & H, Kissimmee, FL 34744

Phone: (407) 606-6441 | (407) 863-4646

Website: Visit Site

RepairTech Automotive is the kind of shop drivers find when they’re out of options, and then never stop recommending. This veteran-owned, full-service repair shop is known for advanced diagnostics, transparent inspections, and repairs done right the first time.

Servicing all makes and models, including European, domestic, and hybrid vehicles, RepairTech handles everything from engine diagnostics and A/C repair to cooling systems, check engine lights, and factory-recommended maintenance.

Customers consistently praise owner Charlie and his team for keeping them informed with digital reports, photos, and clear explanations. Many drivers say RepairTech fixed issues other shops couldn’t, often at a significantly lower cost. Vacation breakdowns, major engine repairs, and last-minute emergencies are handled with urgency and care.

Would you trust a shop while far from home? Hundreds already have. RepairTech Automotive earns loyalty through honesty, skill, and communication that never leaves customers guessing.

Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Kissimmee, Florida – Summary Table

Conclusion

Concluding from the above discussion, we are sure that now you can easily explore the best auto repair shops in Kissimmee, Florida that have earned their place on this list by showing up consistently, fixing problems the right way, and treating customers with respect when it matters most.

Besides, if you need routine maintenance, quick oil changes to complex diagnostics, and collision repairs, these auto repair shops have proven that quality service still exists and trust. Explore other city guides or reach out for personalized suggestions, because your vehicle deserves the best, and so do you.

Here’s what really matters: certified technicians, transparent pricing, and reviews that tell the same story again and again. Every auto repair shop in this list is evaluated using public feedback, ratings, and hands-on industry insight.

Therefore, these auto repair businesses combine technical skill, transparent service, and genuine care for their clients’ vehicles, giving you peace of mind that your car is in capable hands.

If you’re exploring other Florida cities or need a recommendation that fits your exact situation, take a look at our city guides or reach out. The right shop makes all the difference.