Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Collins, Colorado

Let’s be real, one wrong choice can mean wasted money, repeat visits, or repairs that don’t hold up. That’s why this guide to the best auto repair shops in Fort Collins, Colorado, focuses only on real reviews, consistent ratings, and proven customer experiences.

Moreover, nearly 75% drivers worry about being overcharged or misled by mechanics. Plus, studies show most drivers worry about being overcharged or misled, so choosing the right shop matters more than ever. The businesses featured here have earned their reputation through clear communication, fair pricing, and work they stand behind.

These shops offer much more than basic oil changes. They handle complex diagnostics, serious repairs, tires, bodywork, and last-minute problems when timing really matters. That kind of all-around service comes from years of real-world experience, not cutting corners.

More importantly, here at AHS Rankers, we don’t chase trends or marketing buzz. Every shop earns its place through honest customer feedback, proven expertise, and steady, dependable service you can trust.

Now, let’s take a closer look at the best auto repair shops in Fort Collins, Colorado, one by one, so you can easily find the shop that fits your vehicle and your needs.

Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Collins, Colorado

Below are highly rated Fort Collins auto repair shops that drivers consistently trust for honest service, practical advice, and dependable results. These shops didn’t earn trust overnight; they’ve proven it through straightforward communication, reasonable pricing, and dependable workmanship.

1. Jiffy Lube – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.5⭐ (1.9K+ Reviews)

Address: 2549 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Phone: (970) 482-4033

Website: Visit Site

Jiffy Lube on South College Ave stands out for drivers who want fast, preventive maintenance without feeling rushed or ignored. While known for oil changes, this location offers much more, including fluid checks, filter replacements, wiper blade replacements, and windshield chip repairs.

Additionally, customers consistently praise its communication. Staff members explain what they’re doing, listen to concerns, and don’t talk down to you. That matters, especially for routine visits that still affect long-term vehicle health. Plus, the reviewers have often highlighted friendly team members, fair pricing, and extra touches like tire checks or vacuuming at no added cost.

In the same way, many others have mentioned feeling respected and never pressured into services they didn’t ask for. Turnaround times are usually quick, but without cutting corners. For Fort Collins drivers focused on regular upkeep, reliability, and a smooth experience, this Jiffy Lube location earns its strong reputation.

2. Houska Automotive – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.6⭐ (1.8K+ Reviews)

Address: 899 Riverside Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 482-0156

Website: Visit Site

Houska Automotive is one of Fort Collins’ longest-standing repair shops, serving the community since 1952. That kind of longevity doesn’t happen by accident. This family-owned business can handle everything from routine maintenance to complex mechanical repairs, including hybrids, EVs, and even heavy-duty vehicles.

Customers and reviewers have described Houska as the place where they find transparency in the dealership and have excellent experiences. Estimates are clear, timelines are realistic, and technicians explain what’s urgent versus what can wait. The shuttle service is frequently mentioned as a major convenience, especially for longer repairs.

Additionally, many long-term customers say they’ve trusted Houska with multiple vehicles over the years because the advice feels honest and the work lasts. For drivers who value experience, consistency, and local roots, Houska Automotive remains a Fort Collins staple.

3. Big O Tires – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.7⭐ (1.7K+ Reviews)

Address: 1506 North College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 305-4781

Website: Visit Site

Big O Tires on North College Avenue has earned a loyal following by doing two things exceptionally well: pricing work fairly and treating customers like people, not transactions. Whether it’s a last-minute flat repair or a scheduled service visit, the team is known for fitting people in when they can and keeping communication clear throughout the process.

Moreover, tires are its specialty, so this auto repair shop can offer a wide range of services, including brakes, suspension, alignments, batteries, A/C service, and general repairs, making it a true one-stop option for Fort Collins drivers.

Customer and reviewers have consistently mentioned fast turnaround times, upfront explanations, and zero pressure. Likewise, several reviewers specifically call out staff members for professionalism, honesty, and going above and beyond, even fixing minor issues at no charge.

Free alignment checks, flexible scheduling (including weekends), and a strong reputation for ethical service make this Big O Tires location a standout choice. For drivers who value straight talk, dependable repairs, and friendly service, it’s easy to see why so many locals keep coming back.

4. Scott’s Automotive & Tire of Fort Collins – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.8⭐ (1.5K+ Reviews)

Address: 1900 E Lincoln Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 682-4202

Website: Visit Site

Scott’s Automotive & Tire on Lincoln Avenue has been serving Fort Collins since 1993, and its reputation today reflects decades of consistency, integrity, and high standards. This family-owned shop offers full-service auto repair and tire services, covering everything from oil changes and brake repairs to engine diagnostics, diesel service, and major rebuilds, all performed by ASE-certified technicians.

What truly sets Scott’s apart is the customer experience. Customers appreciate knowing what’s urgent, what can wait, and why. The complimentary shuttle service, comfortable waiting area, and convenient online scheduling only add to the appeal.

Similarly, the reviewers have frequently highlighted clear communication, detailed digital inspections with photos, and a no-pressure approach to recommendations. While many long-term customers trust Scott’s with multiple vehicles and continue returning because the service feels honest, thorough, and genuinely customer-focused.

Another major confidence booster is their lifetime warranty on non-wear parts, something that speaks volumes about the quality of their work. If you’re looking for a dealership alternative that combines technical expertise with personal care, Scott’s Automotive & Tire is one of Fort Collins’ most trusted names.

5. McCormick Automotive Center – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.8⭐ (1.4K+ Reviews)

Address: 130 W Horsetooth Rd, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Phone: (970) 472-2030

Website: Visit Site

McCormick Automotive Center has built its reputation on something drivers value more than flashy promises, clear answers, and honest priorities. Plus, this Fort Collins shop can handle everything from routine oil changes and alignments to transmission work, diesel repairs, and in-depth engine diagnostics for both domestic and imported vehicles.

Customers regularly mention detailed inspection reports with photos, clear explanations of what’s urgent versus what can wait, and zero pressure to approve unnecessary work. That matters, especially if you’re trying to keep a car reliable without overspending. In the same way, several reviewers also praise the service advisors for being patient, knowledgeable, and easy to communicate with.

McCormick makes convenience part of the experience, too. Free local shuttle service, available loaner cars, and a comfortable waiting area with Wi-Fi remove the usual stress of repair visits. Backed by a strong 5-year/60,000-mile warranty, this shop earns trust by doing the job right and keeping customers informed every step of the way.

6. BG Automotive – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.7⭐ (1.4K+ Reviews)

Address: 1322 Webster Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 294-7838 | (970) 454-7241

Website: Visit Site

BG Automotive started as a one-garage operation in the mid-90s, and that hands-on, personalized mindset still defines their service today. Located on Webster Avenue, this locally owned auto repair shop offers many services ranges from oil changes and brake work to engine repairs, alignments, and complex diagnostics.

Customers consistently point to thorough inspections, photo documentation, and proactive communication as major strengths. Whether it’s routine maintenance or a major repair, reviewers appreciate knowing exactly what’s happening and why. Many also mention BG’s willingness to work with extended warranties, offer shuttle or loaner options, and provide clear same-day estimates whenever possible.

Long-term customers trust them with multiple vehicles, including trucks, imports, and higher-mileage cars. The team’s focus on education, not upselling, creates confidence, and that’s why BG Automotive continues to earn repeat business and strong word-of-mouth throughout Fort Collins and Northern Colorado.

7. ASR Automotive Service & Repair – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.9⭐ (1.2K+ Reviews)

Address: 309 S Link Ln, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 373-2375 | (970) 900-5785

Website: Visit Site

ASR Automotive Service & Repair has earned a near-perfect reputation by doing one thing exceptionally well: telling customers the truth. This family-owned Fort Collins shop leans hard into transparency, what they call “trans-repair-ancy”, and the reviews back it up.

Plus, this auto repair shop can handle a wide range of services, including brakes, engine repair, transmission work, alignments, and diesel service.

ASE-certified technicians use modern diagnostic tools, and their open-shop policy allows customers to actually see the work in progress. As a result, this level of openness is rare and builds instant trust. From the first phone call to vehicle pickup, customers consistently mention clear communication, upfront pricing, and zero pressure.

Moreover, many customers and reviewers have highlighted fast turnaround times, photo and video explanations, and honest recommendations, even when that means suggesting another shop for specialized work. Service advisors aren’t commission-based, so the focus stays on what your vehicle truly needs.

If you value straight answers, accountability, and skilled workmanship, ASR is one of Fort Collins’ most trusted repair shops for a reason.

8. Christian Brothers Automotive Fort Collins – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.8⭐ (845+ Reviews)

Address: 1500 Academy Ct, Fort Collins, CO 80524

Phone: (970) 540-4050 | (719) 602-7657

Website: Visit Site

Christian Brothers Automotive Fort Collins blends the professionalism of a national brand with the care of a local neighborhood shop. Backed by decades of experience, this location focuses on honest diagnostics, clear explanations, and respectful service, something customers mention repeatedly in their feedback.

Services range from routine maintenance like oil changes and brake work to alignments, A/C repair, and more complex mechanical issues.

Customers appreciate that recommendations are explained clearly, options are laid out, and decisions are left in the driver’s hands. Likewise, the reviewers have frequently noted same-day diagnostics, efficient repairs, and consistent communication through calls and texts.

Additionally, several reviewers mention being treated fairly after negative experiences elsewhere, which speaks volumes. For many drivers, the shuttle service and flexible scheduling make visits easier to manage.

Above all, for Fort Collins drivers who want professionalism, honesty, and a calm repair experience, Christian Brothers Automotive continues to earn long-term trust.

9. Fort Collins Muffler & Automotive – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.7⭐ (828+ Reviews)

Address: 2001 S College Ave, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Phone: (970) 484-0866 | (970) 469-8973

Website: Visit Site

Fort Collins Muffler & Automotive has been a steady presence in the community since 1977, and longevity like that doesn’t happen by accident. This family-owned auto repair shop is best known for exhaust and muffler work, but customers rely on them just as much for brakes, alignments, suspension repairs, oil changes, and diesel service.

Customers say that this auto repair shop is honest, fast, and fair in its services. Likewise, the reviewers regularly mention accurate estimates, sticking close to quoted prices, and zero pressure to approve extra work. Several drivers also highlight same-day repairs, loaner vehicles, and even pickup services, details that make a real difference.

The shop is AAA certified, a Colorado Emissions Repair Facility, and backs its work with a 36-month/36,000-mile guarantee. Add in strong community involvement and decades of consistent service, and it’s clear why Fort Collins drivers keep coming back year after year.

10. Meineke Car Care Center – Fort Collins, CO

Rating: 4.7⭐ (749+ Reviews)

Address: 4263 S Mason St, Fort Collins, CO 80525

Phone: (970) 286-0100 | (970) 449-9267

Website: Visit Site

Meineke Car Care Center in Fort Collins stands out for one simple reason: customers trust what they’re told. While part of a national brand, this location earns local loyalty through straightforward advice, honest inspections, and fair pricing.

More importantly, its services cover everything from oil changes, brakes, alignments, and exhaust work to A/C and radiator repairs.

Many customers mention returning for years because they’re never oversold or rushed. While the reviewers have highlighted quick turnaround times, same-day appointments, and a comfortable waiting area.

Drivers frequently praise the team for explaining what needs attention now and what can wait. That matters. Every visit includes a multi-point inspection, which helps drivers stay ahead of issues without surprises.

If you want dependable maintenance, clear communication, and a shop that respects your budget, this Meineke location has built a solid reputation doing exactly that.

Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Fort Collins, Colorado – Summary Table

Conclusion

To bring it all together, now you can easily find a repair shop you can count on, and you won’t feel stressed or uncertain. Hence, this guide is designed to help you choose with confidence. Every auto repair shop listed here has earned its spot among the best auto repair shops in Fort Collins, Colorado, by delivering dependable repairs, explaining things clearly, and standing behind the work they do.

Trust takes time, and the reviews show exactly how it’s built. These rankings are based on real customer experiences, consistent results, and honest feedback from Fort Collins, Colorado drivers, supported by real-world industry experience, not paid placements.

There’s no guesswork involved. These are the shops local drivers return to day after day. Some stand out for quick service, others for precision and attention to detail, and many for their straightforward, no-pressure approach.

At the end of the day, these businesses have proven themselves through reliability, transparency, and skilled workmanship. Picking the wrong shop can cost you more than money; it can cost you peace of mind. That’s the reason this guide exists in the first place.