Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Peoria, Arizona

Well, to find a skilled and professional mechanic shop that you can trust isn’t always trouble-free; for that reason, knowing the best auto repair shops in Peoria, Arizona, can save you time, money, and a lot of stress. Hence, between abrupt stoppages and the fear of being overcharged, many drivers hesitate when it comes to auto repair.

Certainly, surveys show that nearly two-thirds of car owners worry about getting unnecessary work recommended at shops. That’s why choosing the right auto repair shop matters, not just for your wallet, but for your satisfaction.

The good news is that Peoria has a wide range of highly rated shops, from family-owned businesses that thrive on personal service to large, trusted brands with proven track records. Thus, for routine maintenance, such as oil changes and tire rotations, or more complex repairs, transmission work, and engine diagnostics, you can easily approach professional mechanics in this area who stand by their work.

So let’s explore our expertly and professionally handpicked list of the most trusted auto repair shops in Peoria, Arizona.

Best Auto Repair Shops In Peoria, Arizona

Peoria drivers rely on a handful of highly rated shops for everything from routine oil changes to complex engine repairs. Based on ratings, reviews, and customer experiences, these first two stand out as local favorites.

1. Christian Brothers Automotive Peoria – Thunderbird

Rating: 4.8⭐ (1.8K+ Reviews)

Address: 13675 N 75th Avenue, Peoria, AZ 85381

Phone: (623) 300-2612

Website: Visit Site

Christian Brothers Automotive has built its reputation on something simple but rare in auto repair: honesty. With over 36 years of service nationwide, this shop blends technical skill with a “treat customers like family” approach. Their Peoria-Thunderbird location earns praise for clear communication, fair pricing, and service that never feels pushy.

Customers consistently highlight how the staff takes time to explain issues in plain language, whether it’s brakes, A/C service, or check engine diagnostics. One reviewer noted, “They never try to upsell you. You always receive an honest assessment.” Another appreciated the detailed documentation and lower prices compared to dealership quotes.

What really sets this shop apart is the atmosphere. From awards proudly displayed on the walls to a team known for professionalism and compassion, drivers feel confident handing over their keys.

Whether you are a first-time visitor or a long-term customer, Christian Brothers Peoria makes car care refreshingly straightforward without any discrimination.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Yuma, Arizona

2. Wilhelm Automotive (Happy Valley Location)

Rating: 4.8⭐ (1.5K+ Reviews)

Address: 9715 W Happy Valley Rd, Peoria, AZ 85383

Phone: (623) 299-9750 | (623) 400-7760

Website: Visit Site

With roots dating back to 1928, Wilhelm Automotive has been a trusted name in Arizona for nearly a century. Their Happy Valley location in Peoria carries on that tradition, offering everything from oil changes and brake repair to diesel engine service and transmission work.

Customers say what keeps them coming back is the blend of deep experience and genuine care. One longtime customer shared, “They’ve always been straightforward and honest. Super knowledgeable, and even figured out problems a dealership couldn’t.”

Reviewers often mention how transparent the staff is with recommendations, pointing out what needs urgent attention versus what can wait. Another highlighted the convenience of shuttle rides and the use of photos and videos to show exactly what’s wrong.

The team often mentioned by name in reviews, like Mike, Tony, and Darren, earns trust by keeping customers in the loop during every step of a repair. Backed by warranties and decades of credibility, Wilhelm Automotive has become a go-to for Peoria drivers who value both professionalism and personal service.

3. Greulich’s Automotive Repair – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.7⭐ (1.3K+ Reviews)

Address: 10175 W Deer Valley Rd, Peoria, AZ 8538

Phone: (623) 223-1136

Website: Visit Site

Greulich’s Automotive has been a trusted Arizona name for decades, and its Peoria location carries that reputation forward with skilled ASE-certified technicians and a customer-first approach. They’re equipped for everything from simple oil changes to complex diesel repairs, but what customers really notice is the transparency.

Drivers say the shop goes above and beyond in keeping them informed. Photos and detailed inspection reports show exactly what needs attention, no high-pressure sales.

It’s not just about fixing cars; it’s about creating confidence. Customers highlight fair pricing, professionalism, and the peace of mind that comes with knowing work is done right the first time.

Besides, one reviewer praised their A/C service and clear communication, while another shared how a four-wheel alignment on their Ford F-150 was done quickly and explained thoroughly.

Whether it’s routine maintenance or major transmission work, Greulich’s makes car repair straightforward and reliable.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Glendale, Arizona

4. Kerry’s Car Care – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.5⭐ (1.1K+ Reviews)

Address: 8294 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria, AZ 85382

Phone: (623) 440-2922 | (928) 492-8966

Website: Visit Site

Since 1993, Kerry’s Car Care has built a reputation as a full-service neighborhood shop that really does “fix everything.” Backed by ASE-certified technicians and modern diagnostic equipment, they handle everything from oil changes and brake repair to engine overhauls.

Moreover, what locals highlight most is the human side of their service. Customers consistently note how team members like James, Jason, and Collin treat them with respect and patience, never talking down or pushing unnecessary repairs.

Many reviews mention how the staff go out of their way to help, even with small issues like key fob batteries or patching a tire for free.

Above all, when emergencies strike, Kerry’s has earned a reputation for responsiveness. One family had their Jeep A/C repaired during triple-digit heat while on vacation, while another customer was back on the road just hours after hitting debris in a storm. That blend of technical know-how and genuine care is why so many Peoria drivers consider Kerry’s their go-to shop.

5. Big Brand Tire & Service – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.8⭐ (822 Reviews)

Address: 11790 N 91st Ave, Peoria, AZ 85345

Phone: (623) 979-5001 | (866) 779-8473

Website: Visit Site

Since 1969, Big Brand Tire & Service has been more than just a tire shop. Their Peoria location offers a full suite of auto services, from brake repair and suspension work to A/C service and oil changes.

Drivers say what sets them apart is speed, pricing transparency, and the peace of mind that comes with knowing they’ll honor their “lowest price guarantee” on big-name tires.

One customer mentioned being in and out for tire service in under an hour, while another appreciated an alignment that came with both a coupon discount and straightforward pricing.

Many reviews highlight their willingness to work within customer budgets, with staff like Eric often called out by name for being upfront and accommodating. Even small fixes, like flat repairs or TPMS resets, are treated with the same professionalism as larger jobs.

Adding more, with free alignment checks and rotations, Big Brand Tire has earned a loyal following in Peoria by proving that honest tire and auto service doesn’t have to come at dealership prices.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Chandler, Arizona

6. Midas – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.5⭐ (744 Reviews)

Address: 6845 West Peoria Avenue, Peoria, AZ 85345

Phone: (623) 688-5803

Website: Visit Site

A household name since 1956, Midas continues to deliver dependable auto service at its Peoria location. Known primarily for brakes, tires, and oil changes, this shop also handles suspension, alignment, exhaust, and general engine maintenance.

What customers highlight most here is the approachable, no-pressure atmosphere. One customer praised the team for quickly diagnosing and repairing an A/C system at a fair price, while another mentioned how even their dog was warmly welcomed in the waiting area.

Many reviewers note how staff members like Joe, Alex, and Michael take the time to explain issues clearly, ensuring customers understand what’s critical versus what can wait.

With a comfortable waiting area, competitive pricing, and a reputation built over decades, Midas Peoria remains a trusted stop for drivers looking for reliable service without the hassle.

The shop is also recognized for its honesty, no upselling, just straightforward recommendations backed by experienced mechanics who care about getting it right.

7. Dodge Ram Peoria Service Department – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.7⭐ (700+ Reviews)

Address: 8665 W Bell Road, Peoria, AZ 85382

Phone: (833) 892-4314

Website: Visit Site

The Larry H. Miller Dodge Ram Peoria Service Department is more than just a dealership repair shop; it’s a trusted destination for comprehensive auto care.

Therefore, with a 4.7-star rating from hundreds of reviews, this shop has built its reputation on quality service and transparency. While Dodge and Ram owners are the obvious fit, they also service all makes and models, making them a dependable option for every driver in Peoria.

From routine oil changes and brake repairs to alignments, tires, and warranty work, this team delivers dealership-level expertise with the customer care of a local shop.

Customers consistently highlight the professional, friendly, and efficient approach of the staff. Complimentary Lyft rides, quick turnaround times, and fair pricing are frequently mentioned in reviews.

For drivers seeking reliable, certified service in Peoria, this service department earns its spot among the best.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Tucson, Arizona

8. Scott’s Automotive & Tire of Peoria

Rating: 4.8⭐ (650+ Reviews)

Address: 9660 W Thunderbird Rd, Peoria, AZ 85381

Phone: (602) 363-2948

Website: Visit Site

Since 1993, Scott’s Automotive & Tire of Peoria has been a go-to choice for honest, high-quality auto repair in the community. This family-owned and operated shop is ASE-certified and services a wide range of vehicles, from everyday drivers like Ford and Chevy to luxury imports such as BMW, Lexus, and Porsche.

Their 4.8-star rating with more than 650 reviews speaks volumes about their consistency and trustworthiness. Whether it’s brakes, A/C repairs, diagnostics, or regular maintenance, Scott’s team delivers with professionalism and care, making them one of Peoria’s most respected repair shops.

Customers appreciate the detailed communication, often noting how the team provides clear service reports with photos or videos. The no-pressure approach to recommendations has earned them long-term loyalty from drivers who want fair advice without upselling.

Many also mention the clean, modern facility and added conveniences like shuttle service and quick turnaround times. As a result, Scott’s Automotive & Tire of Peoria will not let you down and provide extraordinary services to you.

9. Meineke Car Care Center – Peoria, AZ

Rating: 4.6⭐ (635+ Reviews)

Address: 8880 W Bell Rd, Peoria, AZ 85382

Phone: (623) 432-9307

Website: Visit Site

Meineke Car Care Center in Peoria is a trusted nationwide brand backed by a strong local team known for dependable, affordable auto repairs. Their certified mechanics handle everything from oil changes, tire services, wheel alignments, and brakes to exhaust, AC repair, radiator service, and general diagnostics.

Customers also appreciate their use of digital updates with pictures and texts, making the repair process transparent and stress-free. Khrystal Cornell praised the team for excellent pricing on new tires and their clear communication about issues.

Consequently, Nisha Calmese called it the “best auto shop experience ever,” highlighting Jennifer’s professionalism and friendly service. Many reviewers note the shop goes above and beyond on warranties and fair pricing, even honoring a slightly expired battery warranty.

Overall, Meineke Peoria blends national reliability with local customer care, making it a convenient choice for drivers who want thorough service and strong value.

Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Phoenix, Arizona

10. Toyota Peoria Service Department (Larry H. Miller Toyota)

Rating: 4.6⭐ (588+ Reviews)

Address: 8633 W Bell Road, Peoria, AZ 85382

Phone: (480) 865-3990 | (855) 765-0728 | (602) 910-4763

Website: Visit Site

Located at the Larry H. Miller Toyota Peoria dealership, this service department provides comprehensive maintenance and repairs for all makes and models, not just Toyota vehicles. Services include oil changes, brake repairs, tire replacement, alignments, and advanced diagnostics, with the added assurance of dealership-level expertise.

Customers, Josh Lockhart said the team “took amazing care” of his Supra, praising advisor Krysta for her attentiveness. Billy B highlighted the professionalism and kindness of the staff, especially their consistent help servicing his daughter’s Camry. Regulars like Janette Cisneros value the shop’s transparent text updates and calls, while others note the quick service turnaround times.

Although some reviews mention higher prices compared to independent shops, customers emphasize the trustworthiness, expertise, and exceptional customer service that make this Toyota service center a reliable option for both Toyota owners and drivers of other makes.

Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Peoria, Arizona – Summary Table

Conclusion

To cut a long story short, Peoria offers a wide range of trusted and best auto repair shops in Peoria, Arizona, for everything from oil changes and brake repairs to complex diagnostics and engine work. Plus, from locally owned family shops to national chains with decades of expertise.

By sticking to top-rated repair shops, you can ensure your vehicle gets the care it deserves without the hassle of second-guessing every recommendation. Besides, each of the businesses highlighted above has earned its place through strong customer feedback, knowledgeable staff, and a commitment to honest and quality service.

No matter which shop you decide on, you can drive away knowing your vehicle is in capable hands. That’s why choosing a reputable place matters. Peoria has an excellent selection to choose from.