Let me clear to you that finding a reliable and skilled mechanic that you can truly trust isn’t always convenient. To help you cut through the noise, we’ve rounded up the best auto repair shops in Surprise, Arizona. Studies show that nearly 80% of drivers feel anxious about being overcharged when taking their car in for service.
So, when you’re going for your last-minute oil change before a road trip or a bigger repair, you need a shop that won’t cut corners. That’s why choosing the right auto repair shop matters more than ever.
Here, at AHS Rankers, we have made the top-rated list of auto repair shops without any discrimination, backed by customer reviews, Google ratings, and real feedback. Now, you do not have to worry about keeping up with routine maintenance or dealing with unexpected repairs.
Thus, here is our expertly curated list of the most skilled and professional names in Surprise, Arizona.
Best Auto Repair Shops In Surprise, Arizona
Now you can conveniently find the top-rated 10 auto repair services having highly skilled staff in the area, known for their consistent service, professionalism, and customer-first approach.
1. Toyota of Surprise Service and Parts
Rating: 4.8 ★ (2.4K+ Reviews)
Address: 13543 North Autoshow Avenue, Surprise, AZ 85388
Phone: (623) 232-0922 | Service: (623) 469-7328 | (623) 469-6027 | (623) 552-5703
Website: Visit Site
Toyota of Surprise Service and Parts is a go-to destination for drivers who want dealership-level expertise with a personal touch.
Hence, if you want to do your routine car maintenance, tire replacement, or recall work, the team’s attention to detail and customer comfort make Toyota of Surprise one of the most dependable service centers in town is big enough for all your repair services.
Customers consistently highlight the professionalism of advisors like Jacob, Tristen, and Eric, who explain services clearly without unnecessary upselling. Reviewers also praise the efficiency; many report being in and out in under an hour for routine work like oil changes and recalls.
The facility is noted for being clean and organized, with added conveniences such as Uber rides for drop-offs and vehicle washes after service. Multiple customers mention being treated with respect, transparency, and care, which builds trust over time. So visiting Toyota of Surprise Service will not let you down!
2. Greulich’s Automotive Repair – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.7 ★ (1.7K+ Reviews)
Address: 16641 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ 85374
Phone: (623) 223-1035
Website: Visit Site
Greulich’s Automotive Repair has built a strong reputation in Surprise for thorough, honest, and reliable service. Their ASE-certified technicians handle everything from air conditioning repairs and brake services to diagnostics and comprehensive maintenance on both gas and diesel engines.
Customers repeatedly note how the staff explains repair needs without pressure and provides accurate cost estimates upfront. Reviews highlight the shop’s ability to accommodate urgent repairs, with many drivers impressed by same-day turnarounds and fair pricing.
Long-time customers mention that the team, including advisors such as DiAngelo, Keith, and Kenny, treats every vehicle as if it were their own. First-time visitors often say they felt listened to and respected, which is why many keep returning.
Above all, for drivers who value professionalism, fair prices, and consistent quality, Greulich’s stands out as one of the best options in Surprise.
3. Big O Tires – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.4 ★ (1.6K+ Reviews)
Address: 16880 W Waddell Rd, Surprise, AZ 85388
Phone: (623) 242-1536
Website: Visit Site
Big O Tires is a familiar name in auto care, and their Surprise location upholds that reputation with reliable tire and repair services.
The shop offers free alignment checks, brake and suspension services, oil changes, A/C repairs, and battery replacements, alongside a wide selection of major tire brands.
Customers highlight how the team handles urgent situations from flat tires to unexpected blowouts with professionalism and speed. Reviewers frequently mention staff members like Jeremy, Noah, Craig, and Hayden for their honesty and clear communication.
Many appreciate the convenience of same-day service, text updates, and early or weekend appointments. Drivers note that pricing is straightforward and fair, with no pressure to purchase unnecessary add-ons.
For residents who want a one-stop shop for both tires and general auto care, Big O Tires delivers consistent service and customer-first attention.
4. Wilhelm Automotive – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.7 ★ (1.4K+ Reviews)
Address: 14297 W Grand Ave, Surprise, AZ 85374
Phone: (623) 544-3676 | (623) 400-7760
Website: Visit Site
With a history dating back to 1928, Wilhelm Automotive has earned the trust of generations of Arizona drivers. Thus, their Surprise location continues that tradition, offering everything from oil changes and brake repairs to engine work, A/C service, and diesel maintenance.
Customers frequently highlight the professionalism of advisors like Michael, Wimbley, and TJ, who provide clear estimates, updates, and even ride assistance when needed.
Reviews often note Wilhelm’s thorough inspections, complete with photos and videos, which give drivers transparency and confidence in repair decisions.
Many locals appreciate the quick turnaround; several mention being back on the road within hours for issues ranging from oil changes to more serious problems like tire separation. Others praise the respectful, welcoming staff who don’t pressure customers into unnecessary services.
For dependable, customer-focused care backed by decades of experience, Wilhelm Automotive stands out in Surprise.
5. Sun Devil Auto – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.7 ★ (909+ Reviews)
Address: 16820 N Civic Center Dr, Surprise, AZ 85374
Phone: (623) 404-1111
Website: Visit Site
Sun Devil Auto has been a trusted name in Arizona auto care since 1978, and the Surprise location continues that tradition with exceptional service. Family-owned and operated, their ASE-certified technicians handle everything from oil changes and brake repairs to transmission work, cooling system service, and even diesel engine repairs.
As a result, Sun Devil is known for their professionalism and transparency; it provides honest estimates, explains maintenance needs clearly, and delivers work you can rely on.
Customers consistently mention the warm, welcoming environment and the staff’s dedication to making auto repair stress-free. Bella calls them her “local service provider of choice,” praising their fair prices and professionalism. Alexia highlights the outstanding customer service from Val, who always goes above and beyond. Shannon appreciated the personable and clean facility, while longtime customer Jonathan commends store manager Val for his honesty and reliability.
Shortly, for your quick oil change, a tire repair, or major engine work, Sun Devil Auto earns high marks for trustworthy service that will keep you and all the drivers coming back year after year.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Glendale, Arizona
6. Meineke Car Care Center – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.2 ★ (887+ Reviews)
Address: 15494 W Bell Rd, Surprise, AZ 85374
Phone: (623) 208-5871
Website: Visit Site
Meineke Car Care Center on Bell Road is a well-known shop offering a full range of automotive repair services, from oil changes and brake work to exhaust, radiator, AC, and tire services. Backed by a nationwide brand, their Surprise location stands out for convenience, affordability, and friendly service.
Customers also mention staff members like Johnny, who receives repeated praise for his friendly, knowledgeable support. From same-day oil changes to detailed inspections with photos, Meineke Car Care Center is a go-to choice for drivers in Surprise who want reliable service and honest advice without the stress.
The reviews show a strong following built over decades. Aaron was “highly impressed” when the team went above and beyond during his Carvana service, while Dominic described his visit as quick, professional, and trustworthy. Stephanie R. shared that her family has been loyal customers here for over 15 years, proving their consistency across generations.
Whether you need routine maintenance or a more complex repair, Meineke has qualified technicians ready to help.
7. Chaney’s Collision Centers Surprise Auto Body Shop
Rating: 4.8 ★ (859+ Reviews)
Address: 13148 W Foxfire Dr #113, Surprise, AZ 85378
Phone: (623) 915-2886
Website: Visit Site
Chaney’s Collision Centers Surprise Auto Body Shop has been a trusted name in collision repair for over four decades. Known for their quick turnaround times, seamless insurance handling, and exceptional workmanship, they’ve built a reputation for taking the stress out of auto body repair.
Similarly, their highly trained technicians use state-of-the-art equipment to restore vehicles to like-new condition, whether it’s a simple fender bender or a major collision.
Customers consistently praise their professionalism and communication, highlighting staff members like Elliot, Kelly, and Josue for going above and beyond to ensure every step of the repair process is smooth and transparent. Many reviewers note how their vehicles came back looking brand new, often exceeding expectations in both quality and customer care.
Adding more, with mobile repair services and recognition as a Preferred Facility for major insurance providers, Chaney’s has become a go-to choice for drivers who value convenience, reliability, and outstanding results.
Read Also: Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Phoenix, Arizona
8. Christian Brothers Automotive Surprise – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.8 ★ (734+ Reviews)
Address: 13930 N Reems Rd, Surprise, AZ 85379
Phone: (623) 624-2889
Website: Visit Site
Christian Brothers Automotive Surprise brings a refreshing approach to car care by focusing on integrity, transparency, and a customer-first mindset.
From routine maintenance like oil changes and AC service to complex transmission repairs, their certified team delivers reliable service in a welcoming environment.
Customers also appreciate the extra gestures, from flowers on birthdays to offering snacks while waiting.
Reviewers highlight their honesty, fair pricing, and dedication to customer satisfaction. Many mention service advisors like TJ, Preston, and JD for their clear communication and genuine care, while others praise the team’s ability to get cars serviced quickly without unnecessary upselling.
They even provide thoughtful touches, like free shuttle service and a clean, comfortable waiting area, that make the repair experience stress-free.
With their motto of “Love Your Neighbor As Yourself,” Christian Brothers Automotive has set a high standard for auto repair in Surprise, making them one of the most trusted names in the community.
9. Sunn West City’s Auto Body
Rating: 4.9 ★ (727+ Reviews)
Address: 17126 N 134th Dr, Suite 1, Surprise, AZ 85378
Phone: (623) 546-4122
Website: Visit Site
With over three decades of experience, Sunn West City’s Auto Body has built its reputation as one of Surprise’s premier collision repair centers that can fix all sorts of damage and other repair work that you need. Plus, backed by I-CAR Gold certification and OEM approvals from leading automakers, they combine technical expertise with a customer-first approach.
The shop offers free estimates, lifetime warranties, and uses eco-friendly PPG Envirobase paint systems that meet modern environmental standards.
Let me tell you some more details. The customers mention how the staff keeps them updated step by step, easing the stress that usually comes with collision damage. From small dents to major restorations, their technicians deliver work that not only looks great but lasts.
Reviewers also highlight the fast turnaround, friendly service, and the peace of mind that comes with knowing their vehicle is in expert hands. What sets Sunn West City’s Auto Body apart is its attention to detail and communication throughout the repair process.
10. All Valley Car Care – Surprise, AZ
Rating: 4.8 ★ (713+ Reviews)
Address: 11541 W Bell Rd Ste. 107, Surprise, AZ 85378
Phone: (623) 243-6206
Website: Visit Site
All Valley Car Care has earned its place as a reliable, family-owned shop trusted by drivers across Surprise. Led by a Master ASE Certified Technician, they bring advanced knowledge to every repair, whether it’s a simple oil change or a complex transmission rebuild.
Their services cover brakes, engines, suspensions, and AC systems, with a focus on precision diagnostics that prevent recurring issues.
Customers often mention how the team explains problems clearly, offers fair pricing, and never pushes unnecessary work. Many also appreciate the welcoming environment and the sense of being treated like family, not just another customer. What stands out in reviews is their honesty and straightforward approach.
With consistent praise for workmanship and customer care, All Valley Car Care has become a go-to shop for drivers who want dependable service from a team they can trust long-term.
Top 10 Best Auto Repair Shops In Surprise, Arizona – Summary Table
| Rank | Shop Name | Rating | Specialties | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Toyota of Surprise Service and Parts | 4.8 ★ | Maintenance, Tires | Visit Site |
| 2 | Greulich’s Automotive Repair – Surprise, AZ | 4.7 ★ | Brakes, Diagnostics | Visit Site |
| 3 | Big O Tires – Surprise, AZ | 4.4 ★ | Tires, Suspension | Visit Site |
| 4 | Wilhelm Automotive – Surprise, AZ | 4.7 ★ | Engines, A/C | Visit Site |
| 5 | Sun Devil Auto – Surprise, AZ | 4.7 ★ | Transmissions, Brakes | Visit Site |
| 6 | Meineke Car Care Center – Surprise, AZ | 4.2 ★ | Exhaust, Radiator | Visit Site |
| 7 | Chaney’s Collision Centers Surprise | 4.8 ★ | Collision, Painting | Visit Site |
| 8 | Christian Brothers Automotive Surprise – Surprise, AZ | 4.8 ★ | Transmissions, A/C | Visit Site |
| 9 | Sunn West City’s Auto Body | 4.9 ★ | Collision, Detailing | Visit Site |
| 10 | All Valley Car Care – Surprise, AZ | 4.8 ★ | Brakes, Engines | Visit Site |
Conclusion
Closing our discussion, the right auto shop can make all the difference in how safe and confident you feel on the road. That’s why our list of the best auto repair shops in Surprise, Arizona, focuses on shops with proven track records, certified technicians, and real customer praise.
These are businesses where transparency, skill, and service come together, ensuring you don’t have to gamble with your vehicle’s reliability.
At AHS Rankers, we don’t sell rankings or accept paid placements. Every recommendation is based on customer feedback, Google ratings, and hands-on expertise.
Above all, if you’re looking for more trusted repair options in other cities or need guidance on where to take your car, explore our guides or reach out anytime.
